Precendents in the Italian Justicial System

Italian Judicial Precedents vs. Case-Law

When considering the substantial differences that exist between the “case law” of a common law court decision or the “precedent” of an Italian court, it is instructive to examine how the differing courts function. A common law court relies on existing precedents for decisions, but may alter or diverge from precedents which are outdated or where facts of the current case significantly differ from precedent cases. These deviations may lead to changes in law or even inspire new legislation. The Italian legal system, meanwhile, operates within a framework where the legislative, executive and judicial branches are completely separate, and consequently only legislative bodies may create new laws. While Italian judicial precedents do exist (usually as a result of legal interpretation by a higher court), due to the separation of powers, they are not a source of law and do not bind judges in the decision of similar subsequent cases.

Italian Supreme Court of Cassation

Taking a closer look at the Italian judicial system, it is worth noting that greater authority is given to Italian judicial precedents that come out of the Italian Supreme Court of Cassation (Corte di Cassazione), Italy’s highest court in civil and criminal matters. The Italian Court of Cassation also has a role in giving uniformity to the legal system, and therefore appeals against decisions of lower courts will automatically be dismissed (without a hearing) when a decision of the lower court has been grounded in a principle “in line with” the current jurisprudence of the Italian Court of Cassation (art. 360-bis c.p.c.). However, as frequently happens, the various sections of the Italian Court of Cassation may adhere to opposing legal principles. In this event, future cases are decided by a panel of judges from the six different sections. This panel, called the United Sections of the Italian Court of Cassation (SS.UU.), creates precedents which sit atop the legal hierarchy in Italy; in cases where the Italian Court of Cassation does not apply SS.UU. precedent, the section must forward the case to SS.UU. and explain their reason for disagreement.

As one can see from this, Italian legal precedents are not like those created under a common law system. Lawyers under the Italian Judicial system formulate and sustain their arguments based largely on precedents created by the SS.UU. or the standard sections of the Italian Court of Cassation. If these are not available, they turn to precedents from an appellate court. First instance court precedents are the very last resort. Likewise, most lower court judges will rely on a higher court’s decision. That said, there is no guarantee that a judge will follow precedent, as each judge is autonomous and can interpret the law as he or she sees fit. Judges must, however, provide sufficient legal motivation, which is subject to evaluation by higher court judges and, ultimately, the I.C.C. (standard section or SS.UU.).

Read also Italy’s Supreme Court vs. US Supreme Court

By |2019-08-11T09:53:30+00:00February 4th, 2019|Blog|0 Comments

About the Author:

I have a passion for helping people and from an early age wanted to become an attorney. My experience in international business has helped to prepare me for working with people of all kinds and on many different levels. I love being a problem solver and look forward to each new challenge. I respect the law and strive to help my clients achieve the justice that our legal system affords each person. I take great pride in helping people do what is right and just. I founded My Lawyer in Italy and put together a group of high quality specialists and associates to serve the legal needs of our community here and abroad. I want to do the very best for my clients and see that as my first priority.

Leave A Comment

General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) EU law 2016/679 on data protection and privacy: we use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.