If someone occupies your Italian property without a valid legal entitlement, must you prove that you had a tenant ready to rent it before you can claim compensation?
A recent decision of Italy’s Supreme Court explains why that is not necessarily required – and why the occupant’s response to your claim matters (Third Civil Division, Order No. 27316 of October 20, 2026).
The dispute concerned a woman who sought compensation after being deprived of the use of property over which she held a legal right of enjoyment. Her claim was unsuccessful before both the Tribunal and the Court of Appeal. The appeal court considered the evidence insufficient to establish the alleged loss and its rental value.
The Dispute Reaches Italy’s Supreme Court
The Supreme Court disagreed. Applying principles established by its United Sections in 2022, it explained that the relevant loss is the concrete opportunity to enjoy the property, whether by using it personally or allowing someone else to use it in return for payment. A claim therefore does not necessarily depend on proving that a particular rental transaction fell through.
Compensation is not automatic merely because occupation is unlawful. The claimant must identify the concrete opportunity for use that was lost. However, the defendant must specifically contest that allegation. If it is specifically disputed, the claimant must substantiate the lost opportunity, including through reasonable inferences drawn from the circumstances.
That distinction was decisive here. The woman had alleged a concrete loss of use, yet the appeal judgment disclosed no specific challenge to that allegation by the defendants. The court had nevertheless rejected her claim for insufficient proof. The Supreme Court held that this approach was wrong.
There is also a distinction between establishing the loss and calculating its amount. Where the loss cannot be quantified precisely, the court may assess compensation on an equitable basis. They do so by using the property’s market rental value as a benchmark.
For owners and others entitled to use Italian property, the practical lesson is clear. The absence of a signed lease or a prospective tenant does not, by itself, defeat a claim for loss of use. How the loss is described – and whether the occupant specifically disputes it – can be decisive.
My Lawyer in Italy® assists international clients with property disputes, recovery of possession, and compensation for unlawful occupation.